The US M1916 Hip Holster and the .45 It Carried for Decades
The first thing you notice about a new M1916 hip holster is how pale it is. Mine came out of the packaging the colour of a digestive biscuit, stiff as a plank, and my .45 flatly refused to go in past the trigger guard. Which, it turns out, is exactly how it's meant to be.
The US M1916 Hip Holster is a reproduction of the leather holster that carried the M1911 pistol for most of its service life. And that's a long service life. Collectors generally reckon the Model 1916 stayed the standard hip holster for around seventy years, until the .45 itself was replaced by the M9 Beretta in 1984. So if you do any US impression from the First World War onwards, you'll probably want one sooner or later.
Where the M1916 Hip Holster Came From
The M1916 wasn't the first holster for the .45. A leather hip holster, the Model of 1912, was standardised soon after the pistol was adopted, and it had a long drop loop with a brass swivel so a mounted man could have the holster move with his leg. There was a dismounted version too, with the same long loop but no swivel.
The swivel was the problem. Forum threads on the M1912 describe it as the weak point, the part that broke and left the holster useless. So, just before America entered the First World War, the Model of 1916 was adopted, and the main change was simply that the swivel went.
Sources don't agree on how complete the switch was. Some describe the M1916 as meant for both mounted and dismounted troops from the start. Others say the cavalry hung on to the M1912, and that tankers were still using them in the Second World War until the stocks ran out. Either way, the M1912 turns up in photographs right up to WWII.
One knock-on effect for collectors (and a warning). Rock Island Arsenal kept making replacement swivel assemblies after 1916 to repair damaged holsters, and these have a habit of turning up grafted onto M1916 bodies to make a more valuable "M1912". The giveaway is that the M1916 has a drain hole at the front and no leather loops for a leg strap.
Two Wars, One Pattern
WWI production M1916s had brass hangers, and collectors say virtually all of them are dated and carry an inspector's or piece worker's initials. You'll see makers like Warren Leather Goods Co. stamped on the back with a year, 1917 or 1918.
Then came a long gap. There were enough WWI holsters in store to cover demand right up until the US became actively involved in the Second World War. After that the M1916 went back into production, and almost 3 million were made by 18 commercial firms between 1941 and 1945, Graton & Knight among them. The WWII ones switched to painted steel hangers, and many lack a date or any inspector's initials at all, which makes dating a loose holster harder than you'd like.
The Marine Corps is a small rabbit hole of its own. The Corps contracted with plenty of leather firms for the M1916 in WWII, probably on the Army specification, and while some are marked USMC on the back alongside the maker and year, there's no documented evidence of wartime contracts carrying USMC on the flap. If you find one with a Marine Corps emblem pinned over the "US", somebody added it later.
Worth knowing, too, that the hip holster wasn't the only option. The M3 shoulder holster came in 1942 for aviators, tankers and anyone else who preferred it, followed by the improved M7 in 1944. But on the hip, it was still the M1916.
How it hangs
The original attached by a wire hook on the back that went into the grommets along the bottom of the web pistol belt or cartridge belt. There were also belt slots on the back so it could go on a garrison belt, and a leather thong to tie it down to the leg. Most people forget the thong. Don't.
Wet Forming the Reproduction
This one is made from top-grain cowhide and, in the maker's words, it's accurate "right down to the rivets". The leather is undyed natural finish, and it turns russet brown on its own with age and use. That's the bit I like most, honestly. It darkens from your hands and the weather and your oil, not from a factory vat that makes every reenactor's holster the same brown.
The fit is very tight, just like the originals, and it's supposed to be wet formed. The method is simple enough:
- Wet the inside of the holster with water.
- Wrap a well-oiled pistol in plastic and push it in.
- Leave it to dry.
After that it fits your pistol properly. One customer found out the hard way that the plastic bag needs to be intact, because water got in and swamped the gun, so check for holes first. Several people have used neatsfoot oil or shoe grease afterwards to soften and darken it, and from what I've seen the results go from honey to a deep antique brown depending on how heavy-handed you are. I'd go easy at first, you can always add another coat.
Using the M1916 Hip Holster at Events
On a pistol belt with a loaded .45 inside, it rides lower than you'd expect, and on a long day of walking it slaps your thigh unless the thong is tied. That's period-correct annoyance, mind. It's also why I'd never wear one without the thong.
If you're fussy about your impression (and most of us are), think about which war you're portraying. Brass hanger and a dated back for WWI, painted steel and often no date for WWII. Match the leather to the story too. A replacement just issued in 1944 wouldn't look like it had been through the Argonne.
I've had my M1916 hip holster through a couple of wet weekends and it's held its shape. Anyway, it's the holster I reach for whenever the .45 comes out.
What Our Customers Say About It
One customer wrote that it "Actually looked like an M1916, unlike 99% of the other reproductions." Another, who owns originals, said it "compares favorably with my originals." A third summed up the break-in honestly: "5 stars if you don’t mind a bit of handy work and treatment."
Not every note is pure praise, which I appreciate. One buyer called it "a faithful reproduction of the M1916 holster" but also found the surface texture a bit "pebbled" compared with other holsters they owned. You can read the rest on the customer reviews page before you order the US M1916 Hip Holster for your own kit.
Disclaimer: Historical information provided for educational purposes only. For accurate product specifications and details, please check our product pages, reviews, or contact customer service.
Experience a piece of history for yourself! Check out our authentic reproduction of US M1916 Hip Holster here: Get Your US M1916 Hip Holster












