The negative first and reason for "4" rating. The adjustment buckle literally fell apart when I went to insert the strap. I tried several times to fix it but it was just too poorly constructed and kept falling apart with the slightest pressure. I ended up sewing the straps together until I can find a suitable replacement.
The Good. Well constructed, I ordered a "long" as others have stated the legs on these could be rather short. Glad I did! I also went a size up on waist bc these are cotton and they did shrink some but not much as I thought they would although I cold water wash and low heat dried them. Still a tad big but not by much and they have brace buttons along with belt loop so not really an issue. I really like these despite the buckle issue. I wouldn't not recommend these bc of the buckle as the material, buttons and fit a very good, just get the long size unless you are on the short side.

Ed - Virginia United States

bought these about half a year ago, they have been great quality, and held together very well in reenactments. No complaints!

Jaffar - Kansas United States

I picked up 2 more pair for the reason that I like the fit and color. I do alot of living history and having some extra poairs of clothes is a necessity.

Sauter - US